We mean that he or she is like everyone else, behaves as most people behave, and stays within current conventions. Normal folk are certainly not religious, or if they are they keep quiet about it. But they do have a problem, because now-a-days the idea of what is normal changes from one decade to another. Fortunately the popular press keeps them up-to-date by surveys and advice columns.
A recent survey in the US is supposed to show that most people commit adultery, so now we know that fidelity and marriage are abnormal and therefore a little shameful.
How does this fit in with 'Living By The Book'? (i.e. the theme of this talk)
There is an Arabic word frequently occurring in the Quran:
'aktharuhum': it means most of them, most people.
And if you obey most of those in the earth, they will lead
you astray from Allah's way; they follow but conjecture and they
Sura The Cattle (6), verses 115/6
'Beware in an irreligious age of doing as others do.'
Normality in fact has nothing to do with statistics. It refers to a norm, a model of perfection, an example to be followed. It indicates what we should be. Normality is therefore something to strive for, something at which to aim, it is not what most people do. It is what they would do if they lived up to their human potential.Some catholic poet said that the only real failure in life if the failure to achieve sanctity, a view with which muslims can agree in terms of what we call 'ihsaan', meaning spiritual excellence.
For us this excellence is exemplified in the Prophet of Islam, Muhammad ﷺ he is the human norm for every muslim. We fall short of that norm, of course we do, what matters most, is where we fix our eyes and aim our intentions, rather than whether we actually hit the target. And one day maybe - just maybe - He will lift us up. And since the greatest distance means nothing to Him, bring us home in a flash.
God's messengers according to the Quran say to the doubters, the questioners, as they have said from the beginning of time:
And what reason have we that we should not rely on
Allah? And He has indeed guided us in our ways; and
certainly we would bear with patience your persecution of
us; and on Allah should the reliant rely.
Sura Ibrahim (14), verses 10/11
And this involves living up to our human potential.
The word 'human' has different meanings for different people; for secular thought: man is a clever animal, whose potential is to become even more clever, until it is master of all.
For Islam, as for Christianity, humanity can only be defined in relation to God. We are, it is said, made in His image, not in the image of a wolf, a monkey or a rat.
Today when people are urged to be themselves and develop their full potential, no distinction is made between the highest of which we are capable and the lowest, which is very low indeed.
Perhaps it is just as well that this advice is seldom taken literally. In real life most people would still rather be someone else than themselves, whether it is the matter of a boy or girl, modelling themselves on a popstar, or an older person, imitating someone they admire.
One way or another people do need to look beyond themselves for a model. But what kind of model? It has been said with good reason, that those who do not aim at the highest, are likely to aim at the lowest. And muslims say, that those who refuse to obey God, will inevitable end up by obeying the devil.
Why should we obey either? Because we are human. And the fact is that human beings are not self-sufficient. The Quran tells us:
Think of the infant, totally dependant; think of the aged man or woman, no less dependant. There is an interval between the two ends of life, during which we can pretend to be in command of ourselves, but it's only a pretense.
Watch any succesful man or woman when disaster strikes, ...it was all a big act. At heart most people know this, which is why most people deep down are afraid. But only when we acknowledge our dependance, can we expect support from Him, who is alone Independant. God speaks thus in the Quran:
And return to your Lord time after time and submit to
Him before there comes to you the punishment, then you shall
not be helped.
Sura The Companions (39), verses 53/54
The Quran frequently substitutes the name ar-Rahman, the All-Merciful for the name of Allah. Overflowing mercy created (all) what is created, and how could mercy leave this creation to its own devices. It did not - hence the books, revelations, the words of guidance. But words are not always enough. We need to be shown how the book's guidance works out in real life and so we have been given a norm. A living reading exempler.
"His nature is that of the Quran."
In short he ﷺ embodied the Quran and demonstrated it, day-in and day-out, what the book means. For the muslim, 'living by the book' means above all else, following the example of the man ﷺ through whom the book was transmitted to mankind and since he is supremely lovable, doing so most willingly, as labourer of love.
Signs Of The Times
Explanation of Human Norm: the fitrah
Society: Islamic View on Peace and Justice in Society
Crisis Of The Modern World; René Guénon / 'Abd al-Wâhid Yahya
Shaykh 'Abd al-Wâhid Yahya, René Guénon