Living Islam - Islamic Tradition logo for mobile phone

Postmodernism And Modernity

Postmodernity Is About Weakening Foundational Sources

Truth Is Meaningless?

For many of our fellow citicens truth seems to mean less, at least as long as this truth doesn't conflict with pre-formed opinions. This trend is supported and reinforced by certain members among the 1‰ power-elites.

Helen Pluckrose: ”The cluster of ideas and values at the root of postmodernism with its irrational and identitarian characteristics have broken the bounds of academia and gained great cultural and ever more political power in western society.

Postmodernism threatens to return us to an irrational and tribal post-modern culture.

As one of its proponents (M. Foucault) asserted: ”It is meaningless to speak in the name of, or against, Reason, Truth, or Knowledge.”

Postmodernism draws on earlier philosophical ideas for its anti-realism and rejection of the concept of the unified and coherent individual.

It even attacks modern science and its goal of attaining objective knowledge about a reality which exists independently of human perceptions.

We see in postmodernism an explicit epistemic relativity (belief in personal or culturally specific truths or facts) and the advocacy of privileging “lived experience” over empirical evidence.”

How French “Intellectuals” Ruined the West: Postmodernism and Its Impact
by Helen Pluckrose, March 27, 2017

Postmodernity (or postmodernism) is really about weakening foundational sources, attacking traditions that have traditionally been like security blankets for people [□ comment: that have traditionally been beacons of light in an otherwise world of darkness] and it prides itself on that in the name of like "a post Hellenistic" kind of white supremacy complete like "barbarianism".

So it careens into traditions [bends, tilts, turns on its side] in the name of "reason" - in the name of "rational" [or: rationality], it tries to undermine people's traditions, because postmodernism finds power in chaos, because there is now no interpretive source, so then it's just a free-for-all and that free-for-all is its authority, it's very dangerous.

Postmodernism Shaykh Suhaib Webb
The 2020 Series: On Religious Revival and Stagnation, 2020-01-14

A Tribal Postmodern Culture?

Modernity (or modernism) and especially postmodernism are cultural, sociological and epistemological developments which inform the political discourse and the orientation of the ruling elites and influence the mentality of the general public.

We need to understand the consistent ideas at the root of postmodernism if we wish to counter those ideas, because they are folse ideas, without any real basis.

This is especially important for people of monotheism and servants of God - Allah, otherwise this irrational social justice activism will usher us into a new kind of tribal postmodern culture.

Stacks Image 326


In modernity it is claimed that materiality or phenomena is everything there is and superior to anything else. This philosophy of science is called positivism - it rejects metaphysics, as it posits that the goal of knowledge is simply to describe the phenomena that we can observe and measure and nothing beyond that.
 More on Metaphysics

But modernity not only rejected tradition, but instead of faith in the Supernatural - in God, it also ”prioritized individualism, freedom and formal equality; (and) ’faith’ in inevitable social, scientific and technological progress, rationalization and professionalization, a movement from feudalism (or agrarianism) toward capitalism and the market economy, industrialization, urbanization and secularization, the development of the nation-state, representative democracy, public education.”*

So the essence of modernity (and postmodernity) is that they rejected the noble truths that all religions, especially Islam hold as sacred. These truths are summed up accurately by the three principles of Islam:

Tawhîd (the unity of Allah), prophecy, and return (return to Allah). Although Islam has the clearest and most stringent expression of the Oneness of the Divine, the old wisdom traditions have some traces left, which may seem they accept the Supreme Reality as One.

Muslims recognize that wisdom and guidance are derived from this Supreme Reality and that humans cannot find permanent happiness or salvation on their own terms and without the help of God - Allah.

Modern art, Red, Orsnge and Blue

Modern art as a mirror of modernity: Expression and show for its own sake as its whole meaning. (Unsplash picture, Steve Johnson).


Nothing really seems to matter - as long as your desires are served.

Case example: Postmodernist Art A. Warhol

… too low ambition!

Stacks Image 328

In Search for Knowledge

This is a knowledge about what is real and true - in its essential sense - about what is permanent, everlasting, non-changing and therefore lifegiving, happyness and bliss. It is the knowledge of God.

In premodern times, the search for knowledge was always about oneself (one’s soul) in relation to Allah - God (may His Majesty be exalted).

We need to find the meaning for our existence (finding our selves or souls) through listening to the Divine Speech in the form of revelation and act in accordance with it.

It is man who is veiled from God.

The Divine Being is not veiled from us, we are veiled from God and it is for us to try to rend this veil asunder, to try to know Allah. Our intelligence is a God-given instrument whose ultimate object is Allah or God Himself.

 Man Is Veiled From God - Allah, S H Nasr

With the advent of the Renaissance and the "Enlightenment" period and the centuries thereafter, people gradually came to believe that they could evolve or improve their situation better with less and even without any divine guidance. A false and extreme reaction to existing problems in Western society and Western religion.

The Very Meaning of Modernity

It is to dismiss the divine revelations and their guidance for mankind and living without the wisdom of the sages. This is not really ’progress’, but falling back and great loss. It is focusing on the ever changing worldly situation, on the 'becoming', ignoring transcendance and the eternal. One aspect of this decadence is that sinister subhuman influences could emerge unhindered over time.
 Antitradition And Countertradition

Although modernity and postmodernism are originally Western European paradigms, they have today spread more or less over the whole world.
 Modernism And Postmodern Thought

The Proposition of Tradition

The main idea of tradition is that truth and authenticity must be rooted in the Divine origin, and further that the keys to this truth are found in what has been transmitted from the wisdom of the past, all the way back to the prophets and messengers of God (peace be upon them all) ).

Nonetheless, tradition must be like a living tree; that is, it is not enough to have roots in the past if the tree has died along the way.

Tradition (as it is defined here) has nothing to do with people's manners and customs of the past, but is *revealed * tradition, meaning the wisdom and principles of the divine order revealed to mankind since ancient times.

The similitude of our tradition is a tree, rooted in primordiality, growing in the Now, providing the shade of peace and bliss and branching out toward the heavens!

Stacks Image 330

Gargantuan African Baobab tree - over 2000 years old

The Kali Yuga: René Guénon’s Critique of Modernity, by Thomas F. Bertonneau

Shorturl of this page:


  • from June 1998